Drawings That Look Like Prints

Heindrick Goltzius, A Right Hand, pen and ink. Left: Teyler's Museum, Haarlem, 1588. Right: Private collection, about 1588 

Drawings and prints tend to be conjoined in museum departments. Most people know that drawings are unique products of the artist's hand and can serve as preparatory studies for mass-produced woodcuts, engravings, etchings, or lithographs. A Getty loan show co-organized with the Art Institute of Chicago, "Lines of Connection: Drawing and Printmaking," demonstrates that the relationship between the media is not so pat. For one thing, drawings sometimes come after the related prints. 

Novice art students were encouraged to copy Old Master prints, an easier exercise than drawing from a sculpture or live model. Centuries ago, Lucas van Leyden's engraved series were already so rare and expensive that collectors lacking a particular print would commission an artist to make a hand-drawn copy of the missing image. The fungible drawing would be displayed in lieu of the costly multiple.

Hendrick Goltzius, A Right Hand, 1588. Teylers Museum, Haarlem

That brings us to an engaging subset of the show: drawings created as trompe l'oeil replicas of prints. Unlike a painting, a drawing hardly be hardly be confused for the "real thing" unless the real thing is a print. Creating a drawing that could be confused as a print was thus an ultimate test of draughtsmanship.

Famed as a virtuoso engraver, Hendrick Goltzius drew an iconic picture of his injured right hand, burned in a fire. The brush-and-ink drawing is made in the style of an engraving, something much more challenging than it may sound to someone who's never tried it. Rarely lent, the 1588 drawing (now in the Teylers Museum, Haarlem) is the show's centerpiece. Incredibly, it's accompanied by a near identical drawing, also autograph, from a private collection. The Teylers drawing alone has the inscription.

Maurice Roger, Trompe L'oeil of a Tabletop with Dürer Prints and Printed Matter, pen and ink, opaque watercolor, and varnish, about 1740–60. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

The otherwise obscure 18th-century artist Maurice Roger did a Trompe L'oeil of a Tabletop with Dürer Prints and Printed Matter. Over 36 inches across, it's an amazing production mimicking Dürer prints (some reversed) and pages from books.

Philipp Jacob Gütl and Caspar von Muralt, Allegorical Scene with the Infant Hercules Killing a Snake, pen and ink, 1747. Getty Research Institute
A book on view is a hand-drawn hoax. Both the text and the illustrations were drawn in pen and ink (by two artists) to mimic printed text and engravings in a festival book marking a royal birth. 

"Lines of Connection" occupies all four drawing galleries in the West Pavilion, plus a space in the North Pavilion, across from manuscripts. The latter part, easy to miss, has a group of large-scale, magisterial drawings and prints by Toba Khedoori.

"Lines of Connection: Drawing and Printmaking" is at the Getty Center through Sep. 14, 2025. 

Toba Khedoori, Untitled (grass) (oil, graphite, and wax on paper), 2019–20. Private collection, Switzerland

Comments

Anonymous said…
The exhibits the Getty hosts increasingly seem like something that LACMA either can't afford or isn't interested in. I wanted to claim that's very different from the Met. Or that NYC's main public art museum isn't as much into contemporary-type or so-called ethnic-type (eg, Fowler-type) shows as LACMA is. But a review of the Met's current landing page sure does make me think of LACMA's current landing page.
Anonymous said…
The Met is very catholic in its exhibition offerings. Something for everybody. And if you don't like it, wait 5 minutes.
Anonymous said…
There was a missed opportunity here to show how some artists paint as if they are drawing. See Van Gogh, Jasper Johns, and Jonas Wood.

--- J. Garcin
Anonymous said…
This show is an excellent example of great public education. Like excellent teachers, the curators open for us new doors on art history. That's why they get paid the big bucks (or should).
A quick check of the Met's web site yields roughly 130 print specimens by Hendrick Goltzius, but none showing the artist's injured hand.
-Ted Gallagher NYC
Anonymous said…
Though not as conspicuous, there is an inscription on the second drawing of Goltzius's hand at the bottom right: https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-5812676. Ever grateful for LACMAonFire.
I'm in Philadelphia at the moment. One of the great masterpieces of Western art, by Goltzius, is here:

https://philamuseum.org/collection/object/85733
From the press release shortly after Philadelphia acquired "Without Ceres and Bacchus, Venus Would Freeze":

Exhibition
A Masterpiece in Focus: Goltzius’s Without Ceres and Bacchus, Venus Would Freeze
November 16, 1991–February 2, 1992

This painting of great rarity and superb quality by Hendrick Goltzius is the most important old master work to enter the collections in the past two decades. In celebration of its coming to Philadelphia, the Museum has organized an ambitious and intensely focused international loan exhibition of works by Goltzius that relate to this remarkable painting and clarify its unique position in Northern Mannerist art. When Goltzius created this so-called "pen painting," which combines pen and ink and brush with oil color, it caused a sensation in Europe and was immediately purchased by Emperor Rudolf II for his collection in Prague. Without Ceres and Bacchus, Venus Would Freeze, c. 1600-1603, marks the critical moment when Goltzius, the most famous draftsman and printmaker in Europe, turned to large-scale painting. This exhibition unites the work with the only other known extent "pen-painting" of 1606 from the Hermitage in St. Petersburg, a renowned pen work on parchment of 1593 from the British Museum, and related works from museums in Malibu, New York, London, Oxford, Vienna, Haarlem, Rotterdam, Stockholm and Paris.
Wiki has a downloadable image at 4,037 × 5,185 pixels:

https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hendrick_Goltzius,_Dutch_(active_Haarlem)_-_Sine_Cerere_et_Libero_friget_Venus_(Without_Ceres_and_Bacchus,_Venus_Would_Freeze)_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg
I hope LACMA gives its own Goltzius oil on canvas pride of place in the new set up..
"The Sleeping Danaë Being Prepared for Jupiter"
Hendrick Goltzius (Northern Netherlands, 1558-1617)
1603
Oil on canvas
Canvas: 68 1/4 × 78 3/4 in. (173.36 × 200.03 cm)
Gift of The Ahmanson Foundation (M.84.191)

https://collections.lacma.org/node/249001