Pricing “Silver and Gold”

The most expensive plein air painting deacessioned by the Orange County Museum of Art seems to be Granville Redmond's Silver and Gold. How important is it, anyway?
Many will tell you that "California Impressionism" doesn't count for much in the scheme of art history. They've got a point. OCMA director Dennis Szakacs says he's bought a 1984 Jack Goldstein painting (for $95,000) with a fraction of the proceeds. Just about everyone in the art world (excepting Cali plein air wingnuts) would say that's an interesting and potentially defensible trade. Not that Goldstein's name will necessarily mean anything a hundred years hence: who can know such things?
And that's the point. The swap must be evaluated, at least in part, by whether OCMA got fair market value for the Redmond. In the L.A. Times, Laguna Art Museum director Bolton Colburn termed Silver and Gold “an A-plus, a perfect Redmond, one of the five best paintings he ever did.” He suggests that this single work is worth a million, approximately the reported $963,000 purchase price for all 18 paintings.
In today's flat-world economy, one admittedly crude index of an artwork's marketability is the presence of Internet knock-offs. Want a Redmond-ish Silver and Gold to hang in your great room? Check out these prices.
From China, a full-size (30 by 40-inch) "museum quality" copy of Silver and Gold runs $135. Settle for high quality, and it's only $69.

From Australia, the price is quoted by e-mail, depending on the desired size [sic throughout]: "We sale oil paint direct from our oil painting studio. we supply only the museum quality of oil paintings on 100% cotton canvas from Australia. All our paint are painted by our talent artist who graduated from art university and at least 10 years of experience on oil paintings." (Pictured, screen shot from the "Australian Oil Painting Studio Team.")
Doesn't it say something that the reputation of this one Redmond painting has made it to the oil-painting mills of the antipodes?


Donald Frazell said…
It means there is a market for it, not taht it is great art. Peter Max probably sells far more. But therr is a blue hair set of rich ole biddies along the coast who would love this. But when they soon die ouy, so will the market. except for a few wiccan types out there. Aussies probably get there stuff from China, where labor is a dime an hour for even skilled labor. And who manufacture Thomas Kinkaide.
Marc Dalessio said…
You can probably get a copy of the Mona Lisa too, it doesn't mean it only has a market value.

How can 18 beautiful paintings go for so little to a private collector without anyone asking questions?

Californian Impressionism is not a market that is going to die out anytime soon. Go to any of the Impressionist collections in museums and watch the crowds, then try the same with a room full of Goldstiens.